The Easiest Make-Ahead Sandwiches

Two game-changers for packing simple, budget-friendly lunches. These make-ahead sandwiches help us save money and eat healthy – plus tips for making healthier sandwiches!

make-ahead sandwiches pingraphic

This post contains affiliate links, which means we receive a small compensation if you make a purchase using the links. You can view our full disclosure policy here.

Packing healthy lunches is a lot of work. Maybe it sounds simple, but it’s not. If you pack lunches, you have to be intentional about what you buy, what you make (is it still going to look appetizing in 4 hours?) how you pack it, and how quickly you assemble it in the morning.

You can find a ton of healthy lunch tips online. The internet is full of brilliant practical lunch heroes and enthusiastic overachievers. Today I am sharing the hack that makes the most difference, hands down.

While we don’t eat sandwiches every day, they do make a simple and inexpensive lunch. These sandwiches are also easy to make ahead of time so you can keep a stash on hand and use them between healthier lunches.

Make Ahead = Freezer Sandwiches

What makes these sandwiches a game changer is that you can freeze them without changing the texture or flavor of the sandwich itself. Simply assemble them, place them in a freezer bag (I put them right back in the bread bag that the loaf came in. If it’s homemade sandwich bread, I use something like these.

Peanut Butter & Jelly

Peanut butter and jelly sandwiches freeze perfectly. They thaw and taste awesome by lunchtime.

If your school or workplace doesn’t allow peanut products, use sunflower butter or other alternatives. I have found that making my own specialty nut butter saves a lot of money, and it takes only a few minutes in the food processor (Tip: buy roasted nuts so you can skip the roasting step).

Make it Healthier:

Lunchmeat & Cheese

Same with this lunchtime favorite. Don’t use any condiments (or lettuce obviously). Simply layer the lunchmeat and cheese between two slices of bread, line them back up in the bread bag, and place them in the freezer.

Make it Healthier:

  • Use nitrate and nitrite-free lunchmeat (we find ours at Aldi or on sale at Kroger)
  • Use real cheese (sliced provolone and pepper jack are our favorites)
  • Feeling adventurous? Try this simple homeme lunchmeat recipe.
  • Use this non-crumbly homemade whole grain sandwich bread (good for some gluten-sensitive stomachs too!)
  • When you pack your lunch, add lettuce and any desired condiments or pack them individually (we use leftover mustard packets from Chick-fil-a)

Won’t the Bread Crack?

When you pull out a frozen sandwich, the bread might stick together. Personally, I have never had a problem with it cracking or breaking when I pull them apart into individual sandwiches.

However, you can place them in sandwich bags first if you prefer, then freeze them. If you use sandwich bags to pack your lunch anyway, this eliminates a step the night before or the morning of – whenever you make you lunch.

Generally, I avoid buying and using sandwich bags because they add another cost and they aren’t good for the environment. But like I always say, do what works for you in this season.

Make it a Meal

When we pack these sandwiches, we pack them with several frugal sides to make a complete meal. Sides like:

  • carrots
  • lettuce (my kids are weird and eat lettuce by itself like veggie sticks)
  • plain yogurt (or sweetened with maple syrup or honey)
  • unsweet applesauce
  • hardboiled eggs
  • celery, raisins, and peanut butter (or alternative)
  • apple
  • orange
  • olives
  • sliced cheese
  • half a banana – you know the kind your mom sliced in half with the peel still on so the exposed banana oxidized throughout the morning and turned black and gross by lunchtime? This needs to be part of your kids’ childhood too.

More adult-friendly sides:

  • Salad
  • Veggies & hummus
  • Or any of the above of course – except the banana. Don’t do that to yourself. You served your time.

Since we packed a sandwich, I try to avoid packing another grain or heavy carb and instead focus on fats, veggies, protein, and maybe some fruit.

For some of you lunch-packing geniuses, this is old news. But this was a game changer for me when I figured it out. And whenever I mention freezing sandwiches on Instagram or Facebook, people’s minds are blown.

So I hope these tips help you save money – by packing more lunches because they are easier to pull together in the mornings – and eat healthy – by showing you ways to make them with real food.

What You Can Do Now

  1. How do you make packing a healthy lunch simpler? Comment below!
  2. If you found this post helpful, let us know! Leave a comment, share it on Facebook or Pinterest, and follow us on Instagram or YouTube for more!
  3. Slash your grocery budget and feed your family real food! Get simple, frugal, real food menu plans every month for FREE in the Cheapskate Cooks’ 1-Min Email. Get the next one here.

9 thoughts on “The Easiest Make-Ahead Sandwiches”

  • I had a co-worker who did this for years with her family! She had 3 kids and she said that freezing sandwiches was the best way she managed lunch making in her house. And she always said to never put mayo on the sandwiches. Just bread, meat and cheese. My family is not a fan of sandwiches for lunch, so I’ve never taken advantage of her (and your) advice. But if we were a sandwich eating family-I’d be doing this!! It’s so smart!

    • This one statement makes my WEEK: “… do whatever works for you in this season.”

      Husband bedridden with cancer and its treatment, special-needs kiddos, no family to help, and church not very helpful. I need to keep reminding myself that we are in Survival Mode. I read you guys have been there, too–multiple times. a
      And that it’s OK for things to be “good enough.”. I can’t do everything I used to, including in the kitchen. Thank you!!!!!!

      • Oh, Kimberly, my heart breaks for you. I’m so sorry. You have so much on your shoulders and it’s can feel crushing at times. Praying extra for you today and that you get a boost of God’s favor to do what you need to do and rest in Him.

    • Thanks, Lisa! We are a total sandwich family. I have to work really hard to remind my kids that there are other foods and we should really focus on those and not load up on bread all the time, haha.

Leave a Reply

You have to agree to the comment policy.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.